FlyVaultFLYVAULTEST. 2021Sign in
Cousins by the Tail: The Black Pennell and Williams' Favourite

FlyVault Blogs

Cousins by the Tail: The Black Pennell and Williams' Favourite

Two Victorian wet flies, one English and one Welsh, that differ only in the tail.

By Brent Jones · 2026-11-15 · In the Vault

Lay these two flies side by side and you'd be forgiven for thinking they're the same fly. Black body, silver rib, a sparse black hackle. The only difference is the tail. The Black Pennell wears golden pheasant tippet. Williams' Favourite wears black cock hackle fibres. Everything else is the same, right down to the order you tie it in.

The Black Pennell

The Pennell comes from H. Cholmondeley-Pennell (1837–1915), an English angling writer whose The Modern Practical Angler came out in 1870. Pennell believed a small set of lightly dressed hackle flies could cover nearly all of a trout angler's needs, and the Black Pennell came out of that series. Mary Orvis Marbury's Favorite Flies and Their Histories (1892) quotes him on the idea and pictures yellow, brown and green Pennells alongside it.

The Black Pennell turns up by name in H. T. Sheringham's Trout Fishing: Memories and Morals (1920), page 121, which you can read in the FlyVault Library.

Sheringham, Trout Fishing (1920), p. 121In the FlyVault Library ›
Black Pennell, floss body
Black Pennell, floss body
Black PennellRecipe in the vault ›

Williams' Favourite

Williams' Favourite is a Welsh fly. Mike Dawes credits it to the father of A. Courtney Williams, author of A Dictionary of Trout Flies. Accounts on the Flymph Forum name him as Alfred Williams (1848–1925) and say he never called it Williams' Favourite at all. The name came from his son, who wrote about his father's fly throughout the Dictionary. Dawes notes it is often tied on small doubles in Wales and Scotland and is very popular for sea trout.

Williams' Favourite, floss body
Williams' Favourite, floss body
Williams' FavouriteRecipe in the vault ›

Cousins, not twins

So are they the same fly? Not quite. Pennell and the elder Williams were born eleven years apart and fished in the same Victorian era, one in England and one in Wales. I haven't found anything saying one fly came from the other. More likely, two anglers arrived at the same simple, sparse black spider, and the tail is the family resemblance that tells them apart.

I tied both on an MFC 7077, size 12, and again on a Daiichi 1510 with a slimmer body of black thread instead of floss.

Black Pennell, thread body
Black Pennell, thread body
Black Pennell (Thread Body)Recipe in the vault ›
Williams' Favourite, thread body
Williams' Favourite, thread body
Williams' Favourite (Thread Body)Recipe in the vault ›

Tie them step by step

One set of steps ties both flies. Swap the tail and you've got the other one. The full eleven-step course, with a photo for every step, is here:

Course: Black Pennell & Williams' Favourite, step by stepOn FlyVault ›

Sources

Mike Dawes, The Flytier's Manual, p. 91. H. Cholmondeley-Pennell, The Modern Practical Angler (1870). Mary Orvis Marbury, Favorite Flies and Their Histories (1892), p. 35. Fly Anglers OnLine, Old Flies: Black Pennell. Flymph Forum discussion of Williams' Favourite and A. Courtney Williams, A Dictionary of Trout Flies (1949).

Write your own on FlyVault

Members blog about their flies, their water and the old books, and link it all to the vault. It’s free to join.